From 1816 to 1990: What Has Stayed True About Forestry?

Woodlots and farm fields on PEI, May 2024. Much of the island's forest regrew on abandoned farmland.

In 1990, David M. Smith sat down with an interviewer from the Forest History Society to talk about the history of his field. He had taught silviculture, the practice of establishing and tending forests, at Yale for four decades and carried The Practice of Silviculture, the standard English-language textbook, through three editions. When the interviewer remarked that we never hear from the foresters who actually do the work, Smith answered with a line he clearly knew by heart: “the foresters who practice don’t write, the foresters who write don’t practice.”

He could not place it. He thought Fernow had quoted somebody, guessed at something far back in the German literature, and moved on. The most authoritative silviculturist in the English-speaking world reached for a sentence to explain his discipline’s central blind spot, and it had arrived from upstream with no label on it.

Our research led us to 1816, to the preface Heinrich Cotta wrote for Anweisung zum Waldbau. Cotta may not have been the first to put the idea into words, but his is the earliest version we found. Cotta founded the forestry academy at Tharandt in Saxony, one of the first forestry schools anywhere, and in the preface he gives three reasons his profession is still getting things wrong. The third is that the forester who practises much writes but little, and he who writes much practises but little.

Comparing the content of these sources reveals something about how much progress has happened over 174 years of forestry, with the discipline moving steadily from timber arithmetic toward ecology. However, what we found notable about comparing these sources is how consistent these two experts of their times were in what they commented on.

Forestry typically starts after something has gone wrong

The forestry schools were founded around 1800, largely to determine whether domestic wood supply was sufficient to sustain the rapid proliferation of mining projects. Ironically, within a generation, the profession appointed to curb forest degradation was itself being blamed for the shortage. Cotta quotes the charge directly: formerly we had no forestry science and enough wood, now we have that science but no wood. He accepts the facts and disputes the causation. There would be no physicians if there were no diseases, he writes, and no forestry science without a deficiency in wood supplies.

Smith reaches for the same comparison. Most of the silviculture practised in the world, he says, does not start until the forest is already high-graded (picked over for its best trees, leaving the poorest behind) or cleared, which is like not calling a doctor until you are sick. Forestry is what a society does after it has damaged a forest, and the profession inherits both the degraded starting point and the reputation for having caused it.

This pattern is echoed here on PEI today. Most of our forest has regrown on abandoned farmland, or is regenerating after a clearcut that hasn’t been conscientiously reforested. On PEI, we are looking to forestry to fix our degraded woodlands.

No rule survives contact with a particular site

Forests change over long periods of time, so forestry builds on models that average over a wide range of conditions to make generalizations that can guide decision-making. Along these lines, Cotta’s first reason is that wood grows so slowly that a practice can be prescribed as good and only reveal itself as harmful decades later, after everyone has adopted it. His second is that sites vary so enormously that what many declare universally good or bad proves good or bad only in certain places.

Smith’s best example is sugar maple. In Vermont you are at the warm edge of its range and have to keep the site cool; on Manitoulin Island you are at the cold edge and have to warm it up. The same species demands opposite treatments, so any general rule for growing it is wrong somewhere. Good silviculture, he concludes, comes from analyzing the stand in front of you rather than from a cookbook.

Neither man treats this as a reason to stop. Cotta’s image is light: the brighter it gets, the more unknown things become visible, so anyone who believes he knows it all has not seen much. Smith’s version is blunter. Applied science always proceeds without complete knowledge, and the stand keeps growing while you wait. Acting without certainty is the job.

The evidence does not get handed down

Cotta did not stop at the observation that those who practise rarely write. He spelled out what it does to a profession: “the best experiences die with the man who made them, and … many entirely one-sided experiences are copied by the merely literary forester so often that they finally stand as articles of faith which nobody dares to gainsay, no matter how one-sided or in error they may be.”

This is where the line Smith quoted does its damage. Forestry knowledge is earned in the stand over decades, and very little of it makes the trip onto paper. The people with field experience rarely write it down, and when they try, something usually stops them: a company that treats its methods as trade secrets, an agency that wants every word cleared, or the plain fact, as Smith put it, that a practising forester who publishes is more likely to get in trouble than promoted. What does get written often comes from people further from the stand, and in a forest that grows this slowly, nobody can check it for decades. Smith’s own career shows where that leads.

Selective logging in the Douglas-fir forests of the Pacific Northwest was promoted from 1936 onward on the claim that you could take the largest trees on a cycle and sustain fifteen hundred board feet per acre per year indefinitely. (A board foot is a piece of lumber one foot square and an inch thick.) Smith thought that was roughly three times what such forests could sustain. In the summer after he finished his master’s degree in 1946, he and a colleague, Roy Silen, measured the trial plots for the Forest Service researcher Leo Isaac. As Smith described the study’s results, the stands lost an average of five hundred board feet per acre per year in the first five-year period. In the second they lost a thousand. In the third they reached the fifteen-hundred figure, as a loss. The stands left standing after logging were blowing down, rotting and being killed by bark beetle.

The study finally appeared in 1955 as an obscure mimeographed station report, by which time the agency had already swung the other way into clearcutting and planting. The idea came back anyway. By 1990 Gordon Robinson, a Sierra Club forester, was building on the same 1936 selective-logging model to argue that clearcutting was unnecessary, and the interviewer noted that his book had been in print for about twenty years. Smith compared the ideas behind it to perpetual motion, and said of the failed plots that the world had forgotten. Smith had a name for the pattern: every good idea lives to be run into the ground, and the overcorrection that follows is usually just as large.

The sentence survived the transmission. The data did not.

What changed

Some things did change, and they mark where the continuity stops. Cotta saw the forest as an equilibrium that slowly declines under use; Smith saw severe disturbance as the normal way most stands begin. Cotta believed the great forests could not come back; Smith watched abandoned farmland grow back into forest for his whole career, which is also what happened across most of PEI after the Depression and the war. And there is no landowner anywhere in Cotta’s preface, while for Smith the owner’s objective defines what good forestry is.

Those discoveries are the foundation of what is now called ecological forestry, which future posts will address directly. What is striking is how little they changed the conditions of the work. The forester in 1990 still arrived after the damage, still faced sites that broke the general rules, still could not see results for decades, and still watched good evidence disappear because the people who had it did not write it down.

Why this matters on PEI

Both men’s answer to these conditions is to trust a competent professional on the ground in the stand, a conclusion that suits professionals very well. As a landowner you are entitled to notice that.

The continuity also says what to do with that judgment. If field experience dies with the person who had it, it has to be written down where owners and other foresters can find it, and that is part of what this blog is for. Over the coming posts we will work through the situations that turn up most often on PEI, including overstocked old-field spruce, wind-damaged hardwood, plantations that have peaked and mixedwoods with regeneration already waiting underneath. Much of it draws on a field day spent walking treated stands with a working forester.

Next in this series: what ecological forestry actually means, and the two ways to invest in a woodlot — maximizing its productive capacity, or restoring its endemic character.

Sources: Cotta, Heinrich. 1816. Preface to Anweisung zum Waldbau (published 1817); English translation in Forestry Quarterly 1(1), October 1902, pp. 3–5. Steen, Harold K. (interviewer). 1990. David M. Smith and the History of Silviculture: An Interview. Forest History Society, Durham, NC.